Mining Grace - Dig out as much as you can
« Back to blog

Why we don't do Halloween

The Hollands don't do Halloween.

To be honest, Halloween makes my stomach turn.  I'm a pastor.  I daily face death and its destruction—physical and spiritual.  In hospitals, counseling sessions, and sermons I teach people about Jesus's triumph over sin, death, and the devil.  Mortality, spiritual malevolence, demons, twisted sensuality, devils and the like aren't just costumes at RiteAid.  They are daily realities.

So when it comes around to Halloween and I see ghoulish decorations, 5 year old zombies, 8 year -olds in fish net stockings, bloody corpses in front yards, and resurrecting dead it hits a little too close to home.  How can I laugh and give kids sugar highs when I'm facing grotesque, cartoonish representations of the things that literally haunt people's souls?  Do I really want my kids thinking that death and the demonic are only lawn decorations for a few weeks a year?

I know what you're thinking, "Dude, lighten up!"  Well, I've tried and have been unsuccessful.  I'm not angry at Halloween or the folks that will pad my street on the eve of October 31.  I'm not really all that concerned with the historicity of the cultural practice.  I don't even think there is a whole lot of malevolence going on—in fact I'm more concerned with the relative ease in interacting with Halloween on a thematic level. 

I just can't keep from cringing when I think about it.

It comes down to the cross.  I actually believe that Jesus triumphed over malevolent spiritual forces at the cross—Col 2:15.  The cross has changed me and my affections in ways I could never have predicted.  I'm more serious about death and the spiritual world than I've ever been.  I'm also more joyful in God's power over sin, death, and devil through Christ than I have ever been.

For so many Halloween is about good times, candy, and fun.  Put simply it is joyful frivolity and dress up.  For me it is sobering and sharpening.

So we don't do Halloween.  Not because we think it earns us anything with God.  It's just the way the cross has affected me and my family.

Now for all of the disclaimers:

  1. If you participate in Halloween with a clear conscience then please continue to do so.  I don't think you're a pagan Satan worshiper.
  2. I know not all of Halloween is about death and the creepy.  If you want your little pumpkin to parade up and down the street with Freddy and 12 year old bar maids, then go for it.
  3. I love my neighbors and actively and aggressively look for ways to tell them about Jesus.  The whole, "You're not really into evangelizing if you don't do Halloween" is one of the more stupid arguments I've heard.
  4. I'm not really into Halloween alternatives either.
  5. The whole argument not do Halloween based on its historical basis is silly too.  Although, if Halloween occurred for the very first time this year, would you participate?  Something to think about. 
  6. Don't worry about my poor deprived children.  We have a large tupperware full of costumes and I give them enough candy to make a dentist's drill finger twitch.  They do just fine on the other 364 days a year when it comes to dress-up and sugar consumption.

Loading mentions Retweet

Comments (10)

Oct 27, 2009
Tim Taylor said...
I actually don't see a lot of kids dressed up as ghouls, zombies, etc. in our neighborhood during Halloween. It's mostly princesses, pirates, superheroes and the like.
Oct 27, 2009
Joe Holland said...
I'm in a new neighborhood so I can't say about this year.  But so far the lawn decorations are pretty disturbing.
Oct 27, 2009
Matt Henslee said...
Our neighbors have a graveyard that is "Protected By Voodoo" and they're about the least gruesome house.
Oct 27, 2009
Joe Holland said...
That's about the fare here too. 
Oct 27, 2009
Josh Espinosa said...
Walk your talk. We all know this, "Do not be conformed to this world, but be transformed by the renewal of your mind, that by testing you may discern what is the will of God, what is good and acceptable and perfect". And what do we read in I John 1? Walking in the light. My case is more that we need be become a people who are peculiar and so our walk is to be different than our culture if we are to be peculiar. We have an opportunity in our generation as every generation has before us, to do something different.
Oct 27, 2009
Admin said...
I'm with you Joe. Our children are all older now, but we've always pretty much ignored Halloween. For many years we got out of the house and went bowling while the "trick or treaters" came around. We also try to make the focus on the Reformation.
Oct 28, 2009
Mike Little said...
Joe, thanks for the good comments and the thoughtful way you have expressed them. I've struggled with Halloween much in the same way I've struggled with so many other things in our culture. I've ultimately realized that it has to come down to a Christian making an informed decision that is covered in prayer.

One question though. If you aren't into Halloween alternatives, how do you explain to your church/family celebrating Christmas and Easter...which were pagan holidays? The church put alternatives on those days for a specific reason. I'd be interested in your opinion on that?

That the love and gospel of Christ would be made known...
Mike

Oct 28, 2009
Tim Taylor said...
Joe,

I'm curious how far you carry this logic. For instance, would you not watch Ghostbusters? Would you not let your kids watch Scooby Doo since there are a lot of people dressed up as ghosts? Do you not play Cops & Robbers (or the like) with your kids because there's pretend death involved? Are there no lightsaber fights going on in your home?

Oct 28, 2009
Joe Holland said...
Mike, I don't like alternatives because I don't think I'm in a competition with culture for cool holidays.  Christians have already one that one with our weekly celebration of the resurrection of Jesus.  As for Christmas and Easter, no matter what their roots, they are an occasion that our culture expects us to celebrate the resurrection and incarnation of Jesus.  Seems like a no-brainer to me.  Although obviously we don't do Santa Claus or the Easter Bunny, just a whole lot of Jesus. 
Oct 28, 2009
Joe Holland said...
Tim, what's really at stake for me is the trivialization of the demonic.  It's not really a list of ok and not ok media that I keep up in my head.  My boys do play war games with dead toy soldiers and the like.  They are pretending but they understand on their level the reality of war.  And as a side note, they aren't allowed to "pretend" shoot each other unless one of them has agreed to be the "bad" guy.  It may seem silly but we're trying to preserve the aspect of just war in their kiddie play.  As for movies, I don't prefer Ghostbusters but do prefer the Lord of the Rings Trilogy.  What's the difference between a donut gobbling ghost and a Nazgul?  The difference is that one trivializes and the other the rightly portrays truths I consider rather important. 

Again, I'm trying to express how the cross has affected me and my family.  I'm not trying to make a list for everyone or draw some bold line through the gray area in media and holiday observance.  Hope that makes sense.

Leave a comment...

 
Got an account with one of these? Login here, or just enter your comment below.
Posterous-login    Connect    twitter